Valentine & Sons of Dundee were Scotland’s most successful commercial photographers. In the early 1900s, at the height of the postcard craze, they published cards showing scenes from a number of countries, including the U.K., Canada, Australia, South Africa and the United States of America.
The U.K. Company
Remembered today primarily as postcard publishers, Valentine & Sons was a printing and photography business in Dundee, Scotland. It was founded in 1825 by John Valentine and was expanded by his son James, who had studied the daguerrotype process in Paris in the 1840s and was consequently able to add the important element of photography to the company’s offerings in the year 1851. By 1890, the company reportedly had amassed upwards of 40,000 photographic negatives representing scenes from all over the world.
Postal stationery was long a Valentine specialty: in a 1905 advertisement, the company claimed to have produced “pictorial envelopes” over 60 years earlier (i.e. prior to 1845). And as early as 1850, the company was proposing a design for “ocean penny postage”, which — as illustrated below — anticipated many of the elements of the postcards that were to emerge several decades later. The idea of ocean penny postage, as illustrated in the design, was to encourage the development and maintenance of ties among Britain’s Imperial subjects across the far-flung Empire, which illustrates the important truth that the postcard was conceived not as a mere frill or fancy but rather as the product of strategic thinking about the commercial and political importance of frequent and affordable communication.
By the 1860s the company had begun to cater to the growing tourist industry by producing photographic prints with views from around the country. After James’s death in 1880, his son William Dobson Valentine took over the ever-expanding business. Valentine & Sons converted from a partnership of the family members to a joint-stock company in 1896, the year in which it is said to have issued its first postcard. By 1907 — according to an article in the Canadian Druggist, a trade publication — its factories in Dundee and Edinburgh employed 700 people and were turning out 3,000,000 postcards every week. As early as 1904, the company advertised that its “Valentine’s Series” cards included “upwards of 50,000 Different Views representing every town and beautiful scene in Great Britain.” The operation continued until 1980 when the last remnants of the business were sold off to Hallmark, Inc.
The Company’s Arrival in Canada
Nowhere other than in their home country (and possibly not even there) were Valentine & Sons as successful as they were in Canada. The Dundee company and its Canadian successors appear to have produced more postcards in Canada, in a far greater number of distinct designs, than any of their rivals. Despite this, the Valentine & Sons story is not that much different than those of most of the company’s lesser competitors: it is difficult to piece together and especially murky in respect of the business’ early years (which we discuss in more detail, if somewhat speculatively, toward the end of this article).
The firm’s Canadian business began with the arrival of George Clark, a commercial traveller sent over by the main office, in Montreal. That was in 1903. Company representatives were soon sent to Toronto and Winnipeg as well, with the photographer Maurice Lyall (a native of Montrose, near Dundee, and later the creator of thousands of real photograph postcards) serving for a time as the company’s Manitoba representative. The Toronto operation grew into an office at 69 Adelaide Street East with a handful of employees. In 1912, full-service offices opened in Winnipeg and Vancouver.
The Canadian postcards
The earliest Canadian postcards published by Valentine & Sons were uncoloured collotypes of scenery along the main line of the Canadian Pacific Railway north of Lake Superior and in the Rocky Mountains. We discuss some of our research into the early cards at the end of this article. Typically, Valentine postcards have a 6-digit serial number (###,###) on the view side with the initials “J.V.” in a circle adjacent to that number. The main series of numbering begins with a Halifax card as no. 100,000 and ends (as far as we know) with a postcard of Toronto as no. 115,981. There are also two short runs of numbers in the 400,000 range that are found on some cards from the Yukon Territory and a longer run of views from various parts of Canada that begins at 600,000 and continues past 602,000. Other ranges belonged to Valentine & Sons’ branches in other countries, as follows: USA – 200,000s; Australia – 300,000s; and South Africa – 500,000s. Valentine & Sons produced postcards of all Canadian provinces, although there were only a handful from Newfoundland & Labrador, which was not a part of Canada in that era.
Speaking very generally, the earlier Valentine & Sons cards — numbered from the 100,000s through the 105,000s — tend to be more common, while the later, higher, numbers are significantly more likely to be scarce. It is important to realize that the Valentine number refers to the image on the postcard and not to the card itself. In other words, if (for example) an image was published once, then re-published on a card with a different border design and then issued in a “moonlight” version (i.e. a card coloured to look as though the photo was taken at night, in the moonlight), all three of those cards will have the same Valentine number. That is one reason that it is unlikely that we will ever be able to say with certainty how many Canadian Valentine & Sons cards were printed. Even if we succeeded in associating all of the numbers in each of the sequences with an image, it would be nearly impossible (in the absence of company records) to know how many “variants” were produced from each of those images. Moreover, some Valentine postcards are unnumbered, e.g. the “multiviews” — essentially collages of multiple images — that the company produced in relatively large numbers.
In another unusual wrinkle, there are also a number of Canadian Valentine & Sons view cards in which an old image of a scene was swapped out for an updated one, while the postcard kept the same caption and number. These duplicates are difficult to identify.
The Canadian division becomes independent (1909), splits into two (1926)
In 1909, George Clark, Percy McIntosh Black and a number of others in Montreal bought out the Canadian Valentine & Sons operation, incorporating it as the Valentine & Sons United Publishing Company, Limited. In 1926, the Canadian company split into two: the Toronto-based Valentine Black (under Percy Black) and the Winnipeg-based Valentine Edy (under J. C. Harrington Edy). The two companies continued to reproduce some of the existing images, but Valentine Edy, in particular, adopted new numbering systems in its later years. The Valentine Edy Co. ceased operations in 1957, followed by Valentine Black in 1964. The Vancouver office, it should be noted, existed only from 1912 to 1919, although E. P. Chandler, a photographic supplies dealer, had reportedly been the company’s original representative in British Columbia from around 1908 or 1909, according to an account in the Vancouver World newspaper in 1910.
Valentine & Sons in the Canadian Context: Then and Now
As noted above, Valentine & Sons cards are by far the most common “Golden Age” postcards found in Canada. Because “familiarity breeds contempt”, these attractive cards are not always given the credit they deserve. Many of the cards are inexpensive, primarily because they are so common, but others are quite scarce and relatively valuable. Thanks to the prolific production of Valentine & Sons, it is possible to assemble a sizeable collection of good-quality postcards from nearly any region of Canada quite inexpensively. The advertisement below, which appeared in the Canadian Druggist in 1907, gives a sense of Valentine & Sons’ strong position in the market and multitudinous offerings.
Dating Valentine & Sons’ Canadian Postcards
As a rough guide, the following list gives some idea of the time period represented by the main Canadian Valentine & Sons series, divided into “thousands”. The dates indicated are those of the earliest postmark in a small sample of Valentine & Sons cards. There is no claim that the dates in the list are the earliest, but in many or most cases, they should be close to the earliest date:
- 100,000 – 1905 (August)+
- 101,000 – 1906 (August)
- 102,000 – 1907 (January)
- 103,000 – 1908 (August)
- 104,000 – 1909 (July)
- 105,000 – 1910 (January)
- 106,000 – 1911 (January)
- 107,000 – 1911 (December)
- 108,000 – 1912 (August)*
- 109,000 – 1913 (January)
- 110,000 – 1913 (October)
- 111,000 – 1914 (August)
- 112,000 – 1918 (March; in this sequence, we begin to see white border cards and cards by Valentine-Black)+
- 113,000 – 1928 (September; a Valentine-Black card)
- 114,000 – 1932 (July; very few recorded uses)
- 115,000 – 1922 (July; all in sample are Valentine-Black)
- 600,000 – 1908 (March; many of these were published for other publishers or were made as promotional items for the depicted businesses)
- 601,000 – 1909 (December; ditto)
- 602,000 – 1927 (September; the highest number found to date is 602,037, so there are very few cards in this range. Nearly all of them are Valentine Edy cards from Manitoba and Saskatchewan)
*Thanks to TPC members Jack Cline and Ken Elder for dating information on the 108,000+ sequence, which seems to have been distributed beginning in the summer of 1912. A (+) indicates that the date given has recently (as of July 2019) been changed to reflect new information about earlier dates.
Early Valentine & Sons Cards
The first few years of Valentine & Sons’ business in Canada are still shrouded in mystery. Postcard dates from earlier than mid-1906 are uncommon, but examples of postcards with V&S images and numbers have been found (by the TPC’s Ken Elder) as early as 19 April 1905 — that card, however, was one of a series of Canadian Pacific Railway-branded “Canadian Souvenir Post Cards” that used V&S images but which were not otherwise identified with the company. The earliest Valentine & Sons-branded postcard that we have found to date is a collotype of card no. 100,208 “A String of Beauties, Granite Lake, Temagami District, Ontario”, which bears a manuscript date of “August 1905”. The earliest postmark — 1 September 1905 — appears on card 100,348, “University of Toronto – Medical Building”, shown below. The very earliest postcards appear to be the ones with the “Printed in Scotland” notation (as shown below) although examples with the CANADIAN POST CARD back (also shown below) appears as early as October 1905, so it is far from clear which came first.
The U of T Medical Building card not only has the “Printed in Scotland” notation, but also italic captioning and a statement relating to the countries that were then accepting written messages. The italic captioning style was used occasionally in a few subsequent V&S Canadian printings, but the list of countries never appeared again, to our knowledge. Indeed, it had already been scrapped by the time of the Osgoode Hall card shown below (no. 100,353), which is postmarked 18 April 1906. On that card, we see the familiar V&S roman typeface in the caption and, turning it over, there is no “countries” list and the heading has been changed to “CANADIAN POST CARD”. (Just to speculate, perhaps it was realized that “Printed in Scotland” wasn’t the big draw that the Valentine head office in Dundee had imagined it would be, it being surmised instead that Canadians were more interested in seeing the word “Canadian” on their cards).
For More Information
The most complete list of Valentine & Sons postcards is on our “lists” page. Click here for more information. Please contact us if you have any pieces to add to the puzzle!
Valentine & Sons on Wikipedia
University of St. Andrew’s (Scotland) Photographic Archive
Edinburgh Photo History
Luminous Lint- a website with a James Valentine biography and photo archive